| 2021 (fall) |
Patriot League - Owen Masterson (Keenan MVP), Sam Sullivan, Casey Trodden, Ross Olinger, Pat Yesinko, Jason O'Keefe |
| 2021 (spring) |
Patriot League - James Griffiths (Keenan MVP), Vinny Skulsky, Mason Leonard, Ethan Cupples, Casey Trodden, Sam Sullivan, Josh Pires |
| 2018 |
ACL - 1st Team: Cade Chabra, Korey Jones, Magnus Leonard, Robby Violissi. 2nd Team - Braden Killens, James Kolar |
| 2017 |
ACL - 1st Team: Jack McNeil, Eddie Kielty, Brendan Ward, Patrick Barnes, Jake Devonshire, Nick Banks, Casey Phinney, Jackson Phinney. 2nd Team: Danny Hickey |
| 2016 |
ACL - Jack McNeil, Brendan Ward, Neal Parry, Adam Briffett, Brody Reynolds, Chris McLeod, Nick Banks |
| 2015 |
ACL - Kyle Meeken, Sean Burger, Adam McNamara, Fred Allen, Shane Leonard, Danny Dalton, Jack Masterson |
| 2014 |
ACL - Fred Allen, Matt Benson, Frank Catanoso, Danny Dalton, Shane Leonard, Jacob Maher, Jack Masterson |
| 2013 |
ACL - Ben Joyal, Aidan Beresford, Matt Benson |
| 2012 |
ACL - Robbie Keuther, Zach Tedford |
| 2011 |
ACL - Bryan Mey, Mark Pomella, Mike Williams, Joe Hastry, Sean Camire |
| 2010 |
ACL - Jon Fraser, Tom Pomella, Mike Williams, Charlie LaPaglia |
| 2009 |
ACL - Sean Griffith, Steve Sousa, Bob MacNeil, Bob Driscoll, Tom Pomella |
| 2008 |
ACL - Tom McHugh, Matt DiGrigoli, Sean Griffith, Bob MacNeil, Sal Scalia, Steve Sousa, Zach Triner |
| 2007 |
ACL - Dave Garfield, Brad Poirier... |
| 2006 |
ACL - Wendell Chipman, Will Nagle, Steve Good, Jerry Freed, Kurt Leone... |
| 2005 |
OCL - Hugo Souza, Zack Chipman... |
| 2004 |
OCL - Hugo Souza, Zack Chipman, Russ Gray, Scott Doherty... |
| 2003 |
OCL - Todd Faiella, Mike McClellan, Jason MacDonald, Brien MacIssac... |
| 2002 |
OCL - Todd Faiella, Bob Cellucci, Ryan Fletcher... |
| 2001 |
OCL - Jeremy Gonsalves, Chris Martin... |
| 2000 |
ACL - Zach Giles, Bob McDonough, Keith Kent, Sean Morris... |
| 1999 |
ACL - Kevin Degnan, Joe Ferrulle, Lee Generous... |
| 1998 |
ACL - Eric Worley... |
| 1997 |
ACL - Tim Healy, Chris Arouca, Eric Worley, Justin Silva |
| 1996 |
ACL - Matt Kalapinski, Dan Gemme, Mike Marino, Ben Loomis, Josh Silva, Ryan Kent, Tim Healy |
| 1995 |
ACL - Matt Kalapinski, Dan Gemme, Matt Cushman, Jim Cooledge |
| 1994 |
ACL - Ben Cabral |
| 1993 |
ACL - Sean Morey, Tim Cleary, Jay Brown, Matt Bearce |
| 1992 |
ACL - Mike Holte, Jason Cushman, Matt Harrington |
| 1991 |
ACL - Steve Ruisi, Ed Brooks, Mark McDonough, Dan Cahill, Matt Griffith |
| 1990 |
ACL - Sean Bogni HONORABLE MENTION - Mike Manning, Ed Brooks, Steve Ruisi, Joe Souritis, Matt Eby |
| 1989 |
Steve White, Doug Cushman HONORABLE MENTION - Sean Bogni, Mike Manning, Steve Hugues |
| 1988 |
OCL - Derek Holte |
| 1987 |
OCL - Mike Webber |
| 1986 |
OCL - John Hatfield |
| 1985 |
OCL - Bill Keys |
| 1984 |
OCL - Jerry Meyer, Andy Cushman, Steve Worden |
| 1983 |
OCL - Tom Pomella |
| 1979 |
OCL - Ron Digravio, Tai Irish, Steve McDonnell HONORABLE MENTION - Kevin McDermott, Wayne Martin |
